Comptroveby RentSpire

Coliseum Park Apartments

345 West 58 Street, New York, NY, 10019

Market rate 345 units (unit count basis: listing-reported) Built 1957 FEMA/NRI hazard read: Relatively Low

Asking & effective rent by bedroom

Average asking rent across observed units: $15,000. Average effective rent: $15,000.

TypeAsking rentEffective rentAvg sqftObservations
2 bedroom$15,000$15,000not observed1

HUD Fair Market Rent gap

HUD area: New York, NY HUD Metro FMR Area.

FMR comparison not observed for this property.

Amenities

No amenities observed for this property.

Operator

not observed

Nearby comparable properties

Comparable apartments with rent data within 3 miles, ranked by the same similarity model used in the product.

PropertyLocationDistanceAvg askingSimilarity
The Geneva New York, NY 0.11 mi not observed 91%
Hemisphere House – 60 West 57th Street New York, NY 0.53 mi not observed 80%
235 West 70th Street New York, NY 0.67 mi $12,950 79%
The Regent NYC Luxury Apartment New York, NY 0.1 mi not observed 78%
Lincoln Guild New York, NY 0.57 mi $10,740 78%
Yorkgate New York, NY 1.34 mi $14,950 78%
Luxury Rental Apartments at The Summit New York, NY 1.27 mi $8,231 77%
The Hampshire House New York, NY 0.36 mi not observed 76%

Sources & provenance

Sourced from https://www.coliseumpark58th.com/ — 2 observation(s), last observed Jul 29, 2026.

Data age: 19 days. Last observed: Jul 29, 2026.

Market intelligence and decision support only. Not an appraisal, and not a recommendation to set any particular rent. Income-restricted product is never presented as a market-rate comparable — program type above reflects the governed affordability classification, not free-text asset labels.

Open the interactive comp report →