240 Manhattan Avenue — New York, NY Rent Comps

Asking & effective rent by bedroom

Average asking rent across observed units: $5,962. Average effective rent: $5,962.

No bed-level rent observations for this property.

HUD Fair Market Rent gap

HUD area: New York, NY HUD Metro FMR Area.

FMR comparison not observed for this property.

Amenities

#1 Ranked Property Management Company for Resident Satisfaction by Grace Hill Excellence Awards for24 Hour Concierge Service with Doormen On Staff38' Rock Climbing Wall40,000 Square Foot The Wright Fit Athletic Club Open by Reservation5 Grocery Stores within A 3 Block Radius - Brooklyn Fare, Whole Foods, Morton Williams, Gracefully,75 Foot Indoor Swimming Pool and Hot TubAir ConditioningAmerican White Oak Cabinetry In Kitchens and BathsBike RoomBilt Rewards - Earn Points on RentBowling Alley, Game Room and Golf SimulatorBusiness Center - A Quiet Spot to Work From HomeCaesar Stone Quartz CountertopsChildren's Indoor PlayroomClub LoungeCommunity Connect (WiFi Amenity)Copper Mosaic Tile BacksplashesDishwashersElegant McGinley Designed LobbyElevatorExtra Tall Ceiling Heights From 9' to 11'Glass Enclosed Showers*High Speed InternetImported Tile On Bath Floors and Walls

Operator

not observed

Nearby comparable properties

Comparable apartments with rent data within 3 miles, ranked by the same similarity model used in the product.

Property	Location	Distance	Avg asking	Similarity
1399 Park Avenue	New York, NY	0.87 mi	$5,324	70%
300 West	New York, NY	0.6 mi	not observed	68%
Towers on the Park	New York, NY	0.05 mi	not observed	68%
258 Saint Nicholas Avenue	New York, NY	0.67 mi	not observed	68%
UDR Apartments Columbus Square	New York, NY	0.58 mi	$4,405	66%
200 East 131st Street	New York, NY	1.38 mi	not observed	63%
The Columbia	New York, NY	0.81 mi	not observed	62%
No Fee NYC Apartments	New York, NY	0.8 mi	not observed	62%

Sources & provenance

Sourced from https://www.windsorcommunities.com/properties/the-ashley/ — 1 observation(s), last observed Jul 29, 2026.

Data age: 19 days. Last observed: Jul 29, 2026.

Market intelligence and decision support only. Not an appraisal, and not a recommendation to set any particular rent. Income-restricted product is never presented as a market-rate comparable — program type above reflects the governed affordability classification, not free-text asset labels.

Open the interactive comp report →